![]() |
| Interview with photojournalist Tamara Abdul Hadi |
In the 2008 article The
Humanity Game: Art, Islam and the War on Terror, Jessica Winegar lamented
that ‘positive artistic representations’ of Arab men are ‘exceptionally rare’. Throughout
history to the modern day, The
picture of an Arab man envisioned by the iconographies of the Western world deploy
a plethora of stereotypes: the seductive but savage Oriental, the moneyed
sheik, the flag bearing protester to the violent terrorist. Each incarnation
has combined to produce a hypermasculine, and ultimately intangibly alien, picture
of the Arab male. In response to the
one-dimensional image of the Arab man perpetuated by and beyond the world’s news
media, the Iraqi photojournalist Tamara Abdul Hadi has sought an alternative. “I started realizing that I was documenting every day Arab men; the
brother, the father, the grocer, the artist, the business man”. Abdul Hadi explains
that her subjects, from Flying Boys to Picture an Arab Man (2009),
are all represented without pretence: “my aim is to show the Arab man as
human first and foremost”.
There
is a tendency in the Western media at least to view the region of the Middle
East as an analogous, and male, whole – a man’s world of war and subjugation as
personified in anthropologist Robin Morgan’s The Demon Lover: On the
Sexuality of Terrorism propelled by a post 9/11 curiosity. On whether there
is a difference between the construction of the Arab male by both international
and domestic media, Abdul Hadi replies “Yes and no. Arab media comes from Arabs themselves and is therefore definitely
a more diverse image of their own representation. But Arab media, if we are
speaking of news media, does the same thing as the West in projecting a
particular image of a people. There is no way of changing the direction of the
box. We can never place the blame on one side, it has to be fair representation
from both sides. ” It is this dual conflict of representation from Arab
and international media and social norms that led writer and human rights
activist Mai Ghoussoub to
describe the Middle Eastern man’s perception of their own masculinity as
‘tortured’.
At a
screening of Kuwaiti director Meqdad Al Kout’s short film ‘Moustache’ in 2011,
writer Sheyma Buali alerted the audience to the otherwise absence of focus on
the anxieties and issues of Arab men in contemporary culture. “I believe that
Arab men are under represented” Abdul Hadi concurs, “but not in light of how
much Arab women are represented through the veil. I am attempting to represent
the uncovered in its own context, not related to anything else”. Coverage of the contemporary
Middle Eastern art world sees the predicaments of Arab women represented more frequently than that of
their male counterparts. Some of the most well
known female artists that challenge religious and gender stereotypes, such as
as Lalla Essaydi and Shirin Neshat, deal with the female figure in singularity
with a critical eye on her contemporary incarnations under the Western and male
gaze. From ‘Unveiled’ to ‘Re-Orientalism’, exhibitions and the art market have
often capitalised on the rich opportunities for wordplay stemming from themes
tackled by these artists when presenting Middle Eastern art to the world, playing
on deconstructions of Orientalist imagery or the conceal and reveal of the
veil. “I have an issue with women being addressed majorly
through the context of the veil.” says Abdul Haidi “The loose understanding of
the Arab woman, I believe, is further engendered through this medium. We have
to start diversifying our content”.
Picture an Arab Man
celebrates
the physicality of its sitters with a rather sweet sensitivity and impartial straightforwardness.
The men are semi-nude and the approach is minimalist. The titular use of ‘Arab’
is encompassing rather than blanketing: the 38 sitters are reflective of the
large geography but also its diversity, representing Egypt, Lebanon, Iraq and Syria
and beyond. Their poses are often inward, contemplative, sometimes smiling,
with each image breaking through the archetype of hypermasculinity with an
unexpected gentleness. Her goal Abdul Hadi says is to “shed light on the injustices that have put them in
their situation, but at the same time to represent them as humans and not one
Monolithic voice and experience. Struggle is universal.”
“I feel that our generation is the first to truly vocalise a
diverse representation of who we really are,” explains Abdul Hadi. Her portfolio reverberates
with an honest naturalism. Self Portraits from Inside Palestine (Ramallah,
2011) tackles the underrepresentation of marginalised communities and, as with Picture
An Arab Man, as she hands over the camera remote to everyday Palestinians
Abdul Hadi raises the question of autonomy over ones own image. There is a
pervasive sense of the documentary with a focus on the honest recording of the
everyday. The delicacy of the portrait series such as Picture and Arab Man
belies the scarred landscapes captured in other projects: cemeteries that are created
to be the resting places of both people and warheads to dilapidated houses that
show the footprint of war amongst communities.
Tamara Abdul Hadi’s photographs have been published in The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal and The Guardian amongst others. On whether
there is any crossover between her personal and professional work, Abdul Hadi
says “they have definitely intersected at some points, while others are
completely separate”. “I approach both projects the same way through the
lens”.

No comments:
Post a Comment